COVID-19 State of Emergency Alert -The Kentucky Public Service is closed to the public until further notice. The PSC will conduct all business via electronic means. please see the PSC order here:

Kentucky Public Service Commission


Follow @kypsc
Search PSC Site

View Case Filings for: 2019-00444


Case Number:2019-00444
Service Type:Water & Sewer
Filing Date:11/27/2019
Category:Regular
Utilities:

Caldwell County Water District , Lyon County Water District , Princeton Water and Wastewater


Electronic Case
Case Nature:

ELECTRONIC PROPOSED ADJUSTMENT OF THE WHOLESALE WATER SERVICE RATES OF PRINCETON WATER AND WASTEWATER









Case Filings
FilingDocuments
7/14/2020 12:36:07 PM

20200714_PSC Notice of Filing Hearing Documents.pdf

20200714_PSC Notice of Filing Hearing Documents.pdf
6/15/2020 2:57:36 PM

Order

20200615_PSC_ORDER.pdf

5/22/2020 4:46:10 PM

PWWCs Post-Hearing Brief

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

PWWC_Brief_Exhibit.xlsx

Exhibit to the Brief

PWWC_Brief_Final.pdf

PWWC Post-Hearing Brief

Read1st_PWWC_Brief.pdf

Read1st

5/22/2020 4:35:04 PM

Post-Hearing Brief

Mark David Goss Caldwell County and Lyon County Water Districts

Final_brief_-_200522A.pdf
Read_1st.pdf

Cover Letter

5/15/2020 5:37:59 PM

PWWC Monthly Supplement to PSC 2-3

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

PSC_2-3_Rate_Case_Expense_-_May_15_Supplement.xlsx

PSC 2-3 Rate Case Expense May 15 Supplement

PWWC_May_Supplement_to_PSC_2-3.pdf

PWWC May Supplement to PSC 2-3

Read1st_PWWC_May_Supplemental_Response_to_PSC_2-3.pdf

Read1st

5/15/2020 5:19:13 PM

PWWC Responses to Water Districts PHDR

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

Princeton_Certification_of_PHDR.pdf

Certification

Read1st_PWWC_Responses_to_PHDRs.pdf

Read1st

Response_to_WD_Post-hearing.pdf

PWWC Responses to Water Districts' PHDR

WD_PHDR_Employee_Wages.xlsx

WD PHDR Employee Wages

5/15/2020 5:16:25 PM

PWWC Responses to PSC Staff PHDR

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

Princeton_Certification_of_PHDR.pdf

Certification

PSC_4-6_CAPEX_RD_WATER_PROJECT.xlsx

PSC 4-6 Capex Rd Water Project

PSC_4-6_CAPEX_Sewer_Project.xlsx

PSC 4-6 Capex Sewer Project

PSC_4-6_Misc_Billing_Hours.xlsx

PSC 4-6 Misc Billing Hours

Read1st_PWWC_Responses_to_PHDRs.pdf

Read1st

Response_to_PSC_Post-Hearing_DRs.pdf
5/15/2020 1:41:59 PM

Responses to Commission Staffs Post-Hearing Data Requests

L. Allyson Honaker Caldwell County Water Dirstrict and Lyon County Water District

Final_Responses_to_Post-Hearing_Data_Requests.pdf

Responses to Post-Hearing Data Requests

Read_1st_-_200515.pdf

Cover Letter

5/14/2020 10:43:18 AM

Notice of Withdrawal of Post-Hearing Data Request

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

PWWC_Notice_of_Withdrawal_of_PHDR_(01279570xA9D25).pdf
Read1st_PWWC_Notice_(01279580xA9D25).pdf

Read1st

5/8/2020 4:36:38 PM

Post-Hearing Data Requests to Water Districts

Todd Osterloh PWWC

PWWC_PHDR_to_WDs.pdf
Read1st_PWWC_PHDRs.pdf

Read1st

5/8/2020 12:42:18 PM

Post-Hearing Data Requests to Princeton Water and Wastewater

L. Allyson Honaker Caldwell County and Lyon County Water Districts

Post-Hearing_DR_to_PWWW.pdf
Read_1st_-_200508.pdf

Cover Letter

5/8/2020 10:02:09 AM

Data Request

20200508_DATA_REQUEST01.pdf
5/8/2020 9:53:31 AM

Data Request

20200508_DATA_REQUEST.pdf
5/7/2020 1:00:17 PM

Order

20200507_PSC_ORDER.pdf

5/6/2020 11:09:20 AM

Supplemental Response to Commission Staffs Request for Information Item 2

L. Allyson Honaker Caldwell and Lyon County Water Districts

Read_1st_-_200506.pdf

Cover Letter

Supplemental_Response_to_PSC_1-2_-_Copy_of_Cald_Lyon_Wholesale_REVISED.xlsx

Updated Cald_Lyon_Wholesale Excel Spreadsheet - Supplement to Commission Staff Request for Information Item 2.

5/1/2020 12:33:42 PM

Supplemental Response to PSC 2-9

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

PSC_2-9_Utility_Benefits_Survey.xlsx

PSC 2-9 Utility Benefits Survey

Read1st_PWWC_Supp_Responses_to_PSC_2-9.pdf

Read1st

Supplemental_Response_to_PSC_2-9.pdf
4/24/2020 1:33:54 PM

Notice of Filing (Hearing Notice)

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

PWWC_Notice_of_Filing_(Hearing).pdf

PWWC Notice of Filing (Hearing Notice)

Read1st_PWWC_Notice_of_Filing.pdf

Read1st

4/24/2020 11:53:17 AM

Responses to Data Requests

L. Allyson Honaker Caldwell County Water District and Lyon County Water District

Final_Responses_with_Attachments_to_Princetons_First_DR_-_200423.pdf

Responses to PWWW's Data Requests

Read_1st.pdf

Cover Letter

4/17/2020 2:50:33 PM

PWWC Responses to PSC 3rd Data Request

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

AMENDED_PSC_2-1_Pro_Forma_(01269365xA9D25).xlsx

Amended PSC 2-1 Pro Forma

PSC_2-3_Rate_Case_Expense_-_April_16_Supplement_(01269396xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-3 Rate Case Expense April 16 Supplement

PSC_3-10__Salary_Budget_FY2021_(01269366xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-10 Salary Budget

PSC_3-3a_WHOLESALE_RATE_COMPARISON_(01267558xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-3a Wholesale Rate Comparison

PSC_3-4bc_REVENUE_FROM_ZERO__MINIMUMS_(01267559xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-4bc Revenue from Zero and Minimums

PSC_3-6_2015-2019_PRODUCTION_VS_SALES_(01267560xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-6 2015-2019 Production vs Sales

PSC_3-7a__FY2020_Salary_Budget_(01269368xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-7a FY2020 Salary Budget

PSC_3-7b_Budget_vs_Actual_Wage_Increases_(01267568xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-7b Budget vs Actual Wage Increases

PSC_3-7c_KEHP_Historical_Cost_(01267570xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-7c KEHP Historical Cost

PSC_3-7g_Chemical_Adjustments_(01267605xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-7g Chemical Adjustments

PSC_3-7g_MOR_Chemical_Projections_(01269288xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-7g MOR Chemical Projections

PSC_3-7h_LAGOON_CLEANING_HISTORY_(01267606xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-7h Lagoon Cleaning History

PSC_3-7i_Utilities_comparison_(01267640xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 3-7i Utilities Comparison

PWWC_Response_to_PSC_3_final_(01269438xA9D25).pdf

PWWC Response to PSC 3rd Request

Read1st_PWWC_Responses_to_3rd_DRs_(01269476xA9D25).pdf

Read1st

4/17/2020 11:19:52 AM

Responses to Commission Staffs Data Requests

L. Allyson Honaker Caldwell County Water District and Lyon County Water District

Attachment__3-_Copy_of_PSC_2-13(ab)_NARUC_Depreciation_AHV.xlsx

Attachment for Response 3 - excel spreadsheet

Attachment_2_-_Updated_Copy_of_Cald_Lyon_Wholesale.xlsx

Attachment for Response 2 - excel spreadsheet

Attachment_3_-_Copy_of_PSC_1-8_EMPLOYEE_INSURANCE_AHV.xlsx

Attachment for Response 3 - excel spreadsheet

Final_Responses_to_Staffs_DR.pdf

Responses to Commission Staff's Data Requests

Read_1st.pdf

Cover Letter

4/13/2020 2:31:08 PM

Order

20200413_PSC_ORDER.pdf

4/6/2020 3:27:50 PM

Response to Princetons Motion

L. Allyson Honaker Caldwell County Water District and Lyon County Water District

Read_1st_-_200406.pdf

Cover Letter

Response_to_Motion_for_Leave_to_File_DR_Late.pdf

Response to Princeton Water and Wastewater's Motion for Leave to File Data Requests After Deadline

4/6/2020 1:58:24 PM

PWWC Supplemental Response (April) to PSC 2-3

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

PSC_2-3_Rate_Case_Expense_-_April_Supplement_(01264520xA9D25).xlsx

Excel File - April Supplement to PSC 2-3

PWWC_April_Supplement_to_PSC_2-3_(01264523xA9D25).pdf
Read1st_PWWC_April_Supplemental_Response_to_PSC_2-3_(01264527xA9D25).pdf

Read1st

4/5/2020 8:34:18 AM

Requests for Information and Motion

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

PWWC_Data_Requests_to_WDs.pdf

PWWC Data Requests to Water Districts

PWWC_Motion_for_Leave_to_File_after_Deadline.pdf

Motion for Leave to File after Deadline

Read1st_PWWC_Data_Requests_and_Motion.pdf

Read1st

3/27/2020 2:55:13 PM

Data Request

20200327_DATA_REQUEST01.pdf
3/27/2020 2:51:30 PM

Data Request

20200327_DATA_REQUEST.pdf
3/20/2020 11:55:12 AM

Direct Testimony of Alan Vilines

L. Allyson Honaker Caldwell County Water District and Lyon County Water District

Alan_Vilines_Testimony_-_Final_-_Complete_Version.pdf
Read_1st.pdf

Cover Letter

3/12/2020 2:01:30 PM

Order

20200312_PSC_ORDER.pdf

3/6/2020 6:17:28 PM

PWWC Response to Water Districts Request for Information

M Todd Osterloh PWWC

PWWC_Response_to_WD_(01251348xA9D25).pdf

PWWC Response to Water Districts' Request for Information

Read1st_PWWC_Responses_to_2nd_DRs_(01252319xA9D25).pdf

Read1st

WD_1-1_AND_1-2_RATE_HISTORY_(01250943xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-1 and 1-2 Rate History

WD_1-14_Total_Employee_Comp_Pkg_(01249813xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-14 Total Employee Compensation

WD_1-19_PWWC_January_29_2019_-_Revised_Scenario_1_Water_(01251170xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-19 PWWC January 29 2019 Revised Scenario 1 Water

WD_1-19_PWWC_January_29_2019_Scenario_1_Sewer_(01251223xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-19 PWWC January 29 2019 Scenario 1 Sewer

WD_1-19_PWWC_January_29_2019_Scenario_1_Water_(01251222xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-19 PWWC January 29 2019 Scenario 1 Water

WD_1-19_PWWC_January_29_2019_Scenario_2_Sewer_(01251181xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-19 PWWC January 29 2019 Scenario 2 Sewer

WD_1-19_PWWC_January_29_2019_Scenario_2_Water_(01251179xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-19 PWWC January 29 2019 Scenario 2 Water

WD_1-19_PWWC_January_29_2019_Scenario_3_Sewer_(01251216xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-19 PWWC January 29 2019 Scenario 3 Sewer

WD_1-19_PWWC_January_29_2019_Scenario_3_Water_(01251233xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-19 PWWC January 29 2019 Scenario 3 Water

WD_1-19_PWWC_March_21_2019_Sewer_(01251220xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-19 PWWC March 21 2019 Sewer

WD_1-19_PWWC_March_21_2019_Water_(01251221xA9D25).xlsx

(WD 1-19 PWWC March 21 2019 Water

WD_1-19_PWWC_May_30_2019_Sewer_(01251177xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-19 PWWC May 30 2019 Sewer

WD_1-19_PWWC_May_30_2019_Water_(01251176xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-19 PWWC May 30 2019 Water

WD_1-20_OLD_VS_NEW_RATES_WATER_AND_SEWER_(01251084xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-20 Old vs New Rates Water and Sewer

WD_1-21(c)_Chemical_Adjustments_(01251124xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-21 Chemical Adjustments

WD_1-3_Presentation_Graphs_(01251122xA9D25).xls

WD 1-3 Presentation Graphs

WD_1-30_Employee_Wages_(01251045xA9D25).xlsx

WD 1-30 Employee Wages

3/6/2020 6:05:13 PM

Responses to Commission Staffs Second Request for Information

M Todd Osterloh PWWC

Princeton_Response_to_PSC_2_RFI_-_Final_(01252315xA9D25).pdf

PWWC Responses to Commission Staff's Second Request for Information

PSC_2-1_Pro_Forma_(01250241xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-1 Pro Forma

PSC_2-11_Inventory_Expense_2018_(01251490xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-11 Inventory Expense 2018

PSC_2-11_Inventory_Expense_2019_(01251476xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-11 Inventory Expense 2019

PSC_2-11_Maintenance_Work_Orders_2018_(01251534xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-11 Maintenance Work Orders 2018

PSC_2-11_Maintenance_Work_Orders_2019_(01251533xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-11 Maintenance Work Orders 2019

PSC_2-13(ab)_NARUC_Depreciation_schedules_(01250239xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-13 NARUC Depreciation

PSC_2-21_Unit_Cost_Worksheet_(01251226xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-21 Unit Cost Worksheet

PSC_2-23_Flushing_Comparison_2014-2019_(01249823xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-23 Flushing Comparison 2014-2019

PSC_2-28_WHOLESALE_METER__INFO_(01251125xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-28 Wholesale Meter Info

PSC_2-3_Rate_Case_Expense_(01245639xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-3 Rate Case Expense

PSC_2-5_Customer_Analysis_(01251502xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-5 Customer Analysis

PSC_2-7_(Unlocked__Affordability_Assessment)_(01249818xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-7 Unlocked Affordability Assessment

PSC_2-9(a)_Compensation_Comparison_(01249819xA9D25).xlsx

PSC 2-9(a) Compensation Comparison

Read1st_PWWC_Responses_to_2nd_DRs_(01252319xA9D25).pdf

Read1st

2/21/2020 3:14:06 PM

Order

20200221_PSC_ORDER.pdf

2/15/2020 5:04:55 PM

Motion for Extension of Time

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

PWWC_Motion_for_Extension.pdf

PWWC Motion for Extension

Read1st_Motion_for_Extension_(01240761xA9D25).pdf

Read1st Motion for Extension

2/7/2020 2:54:23 PM

Data Request

20200207_DATA_REQUEST.pdf
2/7/2020 12:13:21 PM

Initial Request to Princeton Water and Wastewater

Mark David Goss Caldwell County Water District and Lyon County Water District

Read_1st.pdf

Cover Letter

Requests_for_Information.pdf

Initial Requests for Information to Princeton Water and Wastewater

1/29/2020 1:55:34 PM

Entry of Appearance

Mark David Goss Lyon County Water District

Entry_of_Appearance.pdf
Read_1st.pdf

Cover Letter

1/29/2020 1:53:21 PM

Entry of Appearance

Mark David Goss Caldwell County Water District

Entry_of_Appearance.pdf
Read_1st.pdf

Cover Letter

1/24/2020 3:51:07 PM

Responses to Commissions Initial Request for Information

M Todd Osterloh Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission

Princeton_Response_to_PSC_DR_012420_final_(01229569xA9D25).pdf

PWWC Responses to PSC Initial Request for Information

PSC_1-10_2015_-_2019_hour_Breakdown_-_excel_file_(01226123xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 10

PSC_1-11_2015_-_2019_Benefits_-_excel_file_(01226127xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 11

PSC_1-12_2019_Employee_Wages__Healthcare_Election_-_excel_file_(01226124xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 12 Employee Benefit Election

PSC_1-13_Property_Ins_Premium_Breakdown_FY2019_-_Excel_File_(01228834xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 13 Property Ins Breakdown

PSC_1-13a_Vendors_with_allocated_costs_-_excel_file_(01228835xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 13a (Vendors with allocated costs)

PSC_1-14(b)_Contract_A__Soft_Costs_-_excel_file_(01229284xA9D25).xls

Exhibit 14b Contract Costs

PSC_1-14(c)_Contract_B_Skyline_Tank_-_excel_file_(01229286xA9D25).xls

Exhibit 14c Skyline Tank

PSC_1-14_Depreciation_schedules_-_excel_file_(01226126xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 14 Depreciation Schedules

PSC_1-16b,21,_and_31_FY2017_-_FY2019__USAGE_AND_BILLINGS_-_excel_file_(01226131xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit to 16, 21, and 31

PSC_1-33_Princeton_KY_-_Financial_Health_Checkup_for_Water_Utilities_v1.2_-_excel_file_(01228807xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 33 - Financial Health Checkup

PSC_1-33_UNC_-__AffordabilityAssessment_-_excel_file_(01228048xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 33 - Affordability Assessment

PSC_1-4a-3__-_Payroll_Check_Register_(01228548xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 4a-3 Payroll Check Register

PSC_1-5-1_TRIAL_BALANCE_(01229391xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 5-1 Trial Balance

PSC_1-5-2_Adjusting_Entries_(01229392xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 5-2 Adjusting Entries

PSC_1-6d_-_3_YEAR_DEBT_SERVICE_-_excel_file_(01227530xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 6d

PSC_1-7_2019_Employee_Wages_-_excel_file_(01226120xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 7 - Wages

PSC_1-8_EMPLOYEE_INSURANCE_bill_and_voucher_-_excel_file_(01229258xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 8 Employee Ins

PSC_1-9_2015_-_2019_Wage_Breakdown_-_excel_file_(01226121xA9D25).xlsx

Exhibit 9

Read1st_PWWC_Responses_to_PSC_DRs_(01229627xA9D25).pdf

Read1st

1/10/2020 9:16:57 AM

Order

20200110_PSC_ORDER.pdf

1/9/2020 2:31:55 PM

Order

20200109_PSC_ORDER.pdf

1/3/2020

Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission Affidavit

20200103_Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission Affidavit.pdf
12/30/2019

Caldwell County Water District Notice of Filing

20191230_Caldwell County Water District Notice of Filing.pdf
12/30/2019

Lyon County Water District Notice of Filing

20191230_Lyon County Water District Notice of Filing.pdf
12/27/2019

Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission Notice of Appearance

20191227_Princeton Water and Wastewater Commission Notice of Appearance.pdf
12/20/2019

Order Entered: 1. This proceeding is established to investigate the reasonableness of Princeton's proposed wholesale rate increase to Caldwell District and Lyon District. Princeton's proposed wholesale rate is suspended for five months from January 1, 2020, up to and including May 31, 2020. 3. Caldwell District and Lyon District are made parties to this case. 4. Princeton shall, by counsel, enter an appearance in this proceeding within ten days of the date of this Order. The entry of appearance shall include the name, address, telephone number, fax number, and electronic mail address of counsel. Further, Princeton, with its entry of appearance, shall state its position on the use of electronic filing procedures and whether it has any objection to their use in this proceeding. 5. Within ten days of the date of this Order, Caldwell District and Lyon District shall state their position on the use of electronic filing procedures and whether they have any objection to their use in this proceeding. 6. Requests for intervention shall be filed no later than January 10, 2020. Any party who submits a motion to in

20191220_PSC_ORDER.pdf

12/13/2019

Caldwell Protest

20191213_Caldwell Protest.pdf
12/13/2019

Lyon Protest

20191213_Lyon Protest.pdf
11/27/2019

Princeton Filing

20191127_Princeton Filing.pdf